23.06.2019

Best External Hard Drives For Mac Pro 2017

APrime 1TB USB-C to Micro-B External Portable Hard Disk Drive Build in WD Blue Inside for New MacBook 12” Retina, MacBook Pro with Touch Bar 2017/2018, iMac Pro 2018 (1TB). Nov 05, 2018  Best Portable Drives for 2018. And it's the perfect companion for a new MacBook Pro. Seagate's new Backup Plus Fast portable drive is the quickest and most capacious compact external hard. External hard drives are not only useful for storing data but are an excellent way to transport files from one location to another. Here are our top picks for external hard drives to use with your Mac. Looking for the best portable external hard drive for your Mac? You are at the right place. External hard drives are a necessity nowadays as not a lot of laptops offer a lot of storage space, especially the slim laptops from Apple like Apple Mac Book Air and Mac Book Pro.

Research Wirecutter For: Research Evaluations for the actual world Search Close. Browse Close. If the 4 TB My Book will be out of share or the price goes upward, is usually a excellent and dependable substitute. The Elements is about as quick as our best go with: In our testing, its typical write quickness had been 7.7 MB/s slower, and it took about 5 mere seconds more to transfer a Blu-ray film, but those variations were within the perimeter of mistake. At this writing, it costs just 46¢ even more per terabyte, but prices fluctuate; if you find the Components for less than the My Publication, it's a better buy. This model lacks backup software program, though, and it has a shorter, two-year warranty.

If you're also not support up the essential records and photos on your personal computer, you should start. Your pc's inner push will end working sooner or later, and unless your information is backed up, it'll end up being gone permanently. Fortunately, backing up your information is easy, and getting started requires only a several mins: Read our guidance and that will back again up your data files instantly both to án external hard travel and the cloud.

Wd mybook 1tb

Just backing up to oné or the other isn't enough; getting both on-site and guarantees that your information stays secure from localised threats such as fire, theft, or natural disaster, as nicely as Internet outages or interruptions to the fog up backup provider. A desktop external hard travel is usually a excellent local back-up for a pc that mainly stays left on a table. You should think about replacing your backup drivés between the 3rd and sixth 12 months of use. If your get dies and you have a fog up back-up, you won't get rid of information, but restoring from the cloud will take a quite long time.

According to, hard drives are usually most likely to fail possibly within the initial 18 a few months of make use of or after three decades. About 5 pct of drives fall short in the initial 18 weeks of use, with the failing price dipping to about 1.5 pct for another 18 months. At three yrs of program, the failure rate jumps to almost 12 percent. At four yrs, the failing rate is definitely 20 pct. Knowing from five years of information, Backblaze quotes that even more than half óf hard drives wiIl continue six decades.

If you invest most of your time functioning at one table, you should obtain a desktop computer external commute. But if you regularly proceed between locations, a will be the much better choice. They're even more expensive per terabyte than bigger desktop models, and they're a little bit not so quick, but transportable hard drives are smaller sized and lighter thán desktop drives ánd wear't want an extra energy adapter. They're also also developed to endure a little more mistreatment (although one lump can nevertheless lead to failure).

How we picked. A great external desktop computer hard get, like the three we found, should end up being reliable, quick, and inexpensive. Photo: Rozette Rago Ideally, an external hard drive is something you don't notice significantly. It should sit down on your table, quietly re-writing aside, storing and support up your data without a lot of setup or continuing servicing. These are usually the features you should appear for in a desktop hard commute, in tough purchase of importance:.

Reliability: Although dependability is the nearly all important aspect for any storage device, solid information on commute reliability can end up being hard to arrive. Only three companies still produce hard drives-Wéstern Digital (which furthermore can make HGST drives), Séagate, and Toshiba-ánd all of thém create reliable drives. But aIl hard drives expire. The huge bulk of drives from these main manufacturers will become fine, but it's nevertheless achievable to purchase a poor egg that will expire too shortly. Velocity: Many of the drivés we've examined in 2018 are about the exact same acceleration, and we haven't seen major rate raises in desktop hard drives over the previous few yrs. This round, we regarded as just those drives with USB 3.0 cable connections.

Anything faster isn't essential for hard drivés, because they're also limited by disk speed, not the USB interface. Cost: We found that most people purchase 4 TB and 8 TB drives by searching at Amazon reviews for óur top picks. AIthough a higher-cápacity drive is even more cost-effective pér terabyte, 8 TB external desktop computer hard drives are nearly double as costly as 4 TB drives, for even more storage than most people need.

Since several desktop drives today offer identical efficiency, the less costly they are usually, the better. Capability: We concentrated on 4 TB hard drives because of their balance of worth and overall price. We also have an 8 TB get for people who need more storage space. Guarantee and consumer services: A great warranty will be essential in situation you obtain a lemon.

Many of the externaI hard drives wé tested have two-year warranties, but some possess three-year warranties. Responsive client service is certainly important as well, in case you possess trouble support up your data. Useful software program: Backup software can be a great benefit, but you can find plenty of free of charge options and other great options for on the internet backup solutions. If you don't require the extra features such software provides, setting up it up on every pc you make use of isn't worth the time and work. Pulling and falling files functions just good for manual backups, and your Operating-system's built-in back-up application suffices for automated ones. We furthermore made be aware of drive noise and extra USB slots as we tested the external desktop computer hard drives. These aspects aren't deaIbreakers, but they are usually great to maintain in thoughts.

How we examined. After narrowing our list of finalists by price and capability, we tested four 4 TB desktop hard drives ánd three 8 TB versions. For each oné, we rán HD Beat Pro, a benchmarking plan that checks transfer rates of speed and access time across the whole disk. You can study a even more in-depth explanation of the program at the. We also timed the file transfer of a 45.5 GB rip of a Blu-ray movie from start to finish, running each exchange three times and determining the common to rule out overall performance hiccups. Lastly, we timed how lengthy each external hard drive got to back again up with ón a 2016 MacBook Pro.

To spot any widespread reliability problems, we read through through Amazon . com reviews for éach of the drivés we tested, ánd we counted thé number of réported drive faiIures. This technique has disadvantages: For one, people are even more most likely to write-up a evaluation when they have got a problem.

Also, because of the limited information obtainable in some reviews, it can be hard to distinguish between equipment disappointments and software program issues or consumer errors that could trigger complications with a drive. About half the drives we examined for this upgrade are new, so they didn't possess numerous Amazon reviews. But this approach is definitely the best we have for now. We furthermore looked at Backblaze'h, which are based on even more than 90,000 drives the firm uses in its fog up backup machines. Backup servers are usually a very different atmosphere than a box on your desk: Bare drives in machines are reached more often and are usually subject to even more vibrations and more temperature, whereas drives in desktop computer enclosures have got more possible points of failure between the strength connector, the USB connector, and thé USB-tó-SATA reasoning board.

Actually therefore, the Backblaze study is usually the largest, most recent sample of hard get failures we have got access to, and it's continually a interesting read through. Our find: WD My Book (4 TB). Is usually the best desktop hard push for most people because it't dependable and it provides the best balance of acceleration and cost. It had been about as fast as the competitors in all of our tests, it's the minimum expensive get we tested at this writing, and it provides a longer guarantee (three decades) than the additional opportunities.

Although no hard commute is immune system from failing, the WD My Reserve has proved dependable. We discovered simply 21 reported breakdowns out of 358 Amazon reviews of the 4 TB model, or 6 percent. Records that WD's i9000 4 TB drives had a low, 2.2 percent annualized failing price. Neither of these analysis methods is a ideal indicator of the My Publication's dependability, but they are the best we possess. We tested how fast our 4 TB and 5 TB desktop computer hard drive contenders could transfer a Blu-ray film. They all performed similarly, although the Toshiba Canvio had been a bit quicker than the competitors. Shorter pubs indicate better performance.

Many of the drives we examined performed likewise, with the 4 TB WD My Book having a slight advantage in most of our testing. In our Blu-ray transfer check, all of thé 4 TB drives we tested had been within the perimeter of mistake of one anothér, but the 5 TB Toshiba Canvio was about 30 secs faster than the competitors. (That travel, however, costs considerably even more.).

The 4 TB WD My Guide had been the fastest push we tested at developing a back-up with Period Machine, although all óf the drives wé tested were pretty quick. Shorter bars indicate much better functionality.

In HD Tune assessment, the 4 TB WD My Publication experienced a read speed of 143.8 megabytes per following and a write velocity of 138.4 MB/s, operating a little quicker than most of the competition. And it experienced the fastest Time Device backup score of all thé 4 TB drives we tested.

External

Most of the drives carried out likewise in these testing, except for thé 4 TB Seagate Back-up Plus Hub, which has been particularly slower. The 4 TB My Book will be the almost all cost-effective push we found at the period of our analysis and composing. Although costs on hard drives vary frequently, our get has been the minimum costly in its aggressive industry: At the period, it cost around $96, or $24 per terabyte, while the bulk of the drives we tested cost even more than $100.

Because all of the drives we examined are great, though, we suggest you buy the cheapest option obtainable if costs modify. WD backs the 4 TB My Reserve with a three-year warranty, longer insurance than the competitors offers. The travel did not get warm during our testing, and although this My Publication occasionally made a reduced humming noise while we relocated files close to, we put on't think that'h cause for worry; all of thé drives we examined make some noise. Using the incorporated WD Breakthrough app, you can transfer your data from a fog up storage or cultural media accounts to your travel. You can also use WD Drive Utilities to check out for possible drive failures, major performance troubles, and poor sectors on the My Guide. (In addition, you can use it to completely remove all the data on your drive.) You can switch on 256-AES encryption by downloading it WD'h Security software, allowing it, and setting up a password. Wirecutter staffers possess used the WD My Guide (in varying sizes) with no issue.

Senior editor Nathan Edwards provides possessed the 6 TB version of the travel for about a 12 months: “It's quiéter than my outdated backup drive and fairly good-looking,” he said. “I put on't trouble it ánd it doésn't bother me, and my pc is backed up, therefore that seems great.” Runner-up: WD Components (4 TB). If the 4 TB My Reserve is inaccessible, or if its cost goes upward, desktop push will be a excellent second choice.

It's a dependable travel, although it isn't very as quick as our top go with. The difference in transfer period wasn't significant in any of our exams, though, and it expenses about the same as the My Publication per terabyte. It offers the exact same software program as our best pick as well, but its warranty is only two years-one 12 months less than the My Reserve's protection.

The Elements is certainly about mainly because dependable as the 4 TB My Book. We found just five reported breakdowns out of 168 Amazon . com reviews for thé Elements 4 TB option, giving this external hard drive a 3 percent failure rate. That'beds a lower failure price than our top pick offers, but the Elements has roughly fifty percent as several evaluations at this composing, so the reported failure price may not be similar. In our assessment, the Elements was about mainly because fast as the 4 TB My Book, falling behind in our Blu-ray transfer check by just 5 seconds. In HD Track tests, the Elements got a somewhat slower write speed likened with our best pick, but the two models' go through speeds had been actually.

And when we backed up to the Elements with Period Machine, it was the second-fastest commute we tested, falling simply behind our top pick. The WD Elements provides a two-year warranty, one 12 months much less than our top pick out, and it doesn't come with any backup software. But that ómission isn't á dealbreaker because dragging and shedding files or using some additional free back-up program can be an equally good option.

Like our top pick and choose, this commute did not really get popular during tests, although it do create a little humming sound from time to period. If you need more storage space: WD My Reserve (8 TB). If you wish more space-say, you have got a heap of large photos or movies or an present media library and need space to increase in the potential future- will be the best option. Like our best pick and choose, the higher-cápacity WD My Reserve has a reduced, 6 pct reported failing price (knowing from Amazon evaluations), and it carried out the best óf the three 8 TB options we examined. It'h also much less expensive than the some other 8 TB drives we examined, and it has the longest guarantee. Presently the 8 TB My Book expenses about $70 even more than our top get, though, so we recommend it only if you need the extra storage space.

(We suggest the similarly executing if it's the exact same price as-or chéaper than-the 8 TB My Book. Because the Easystore is usually usually more expensive, we believe the My Reserve will be the much better 8 TB choice for many people's demands.) While reading through through 326 Amazon evaluations of the 8 TB My Book, we discovered just 20 reviews-or 6 percent-that stated drive failing. This outcome was much better than that fór the 8 TB Seagate we tested, which had an 11 percent reported failure rate, or 62 noted failures out of 570 testimonials on Amazon.

The 8 TB Easystore acquired a mere 1.25 pct reported failure rate on Ideal Buy's web site-34 noted disappointments out of 2,708 reviews-but these outcomes aren'testosterone levels directly similar because they're also from different merchants with various demographics and consumer review techniques. The 8 TB WD Easystore had been faster than thé 8 TB WD My Reserve in the HD Melody tests-but not by very much. Longer pubs indicate much better performance. The 8 TB My Reserve performed nicely in our HD Beat read and write lab tests, with results of 134 MB/h and 139.9 MB/t, respectively. It had been considerably faster than the Seagate model in this test, but a Iittle slower than thé WD Easystore, dropping quick by 12.3 MB/h on scans and 5 MB/t on writes. The My Guide also arrived in the middle of the pack when support up via Time Machine, keeping 37.8 GB in 25 moments, 49 seconds.

The Easystore was about 2 minutes quicker in this test. The 8 TB WD My Book had been about as quick as the 8 TB Seagate in our Period Machine backup test.

The 8 TB WD Easystore was quicker than both versions by about 2 a few minutes. Shorter bars indicate much better performance. The 8 TB My Guide is usually cheaper, as of this composing, and accessible at even more suppliers than the 8 TB. If you notice the price on the Easystore come down, even though, it's well worth buying.

The 8 TB My Publication contains the same backup software as our best go with. It also arrives with a longer warranty than the various other 8 TB choices we examined, three yrs of insurance. The competition. We regarded as seven external desktop computer drives for our 2018 circular of screening. (Not pictured: WD Easystore.) Photo: Rozette Rago Every hard get we examined is sufficient for the job of support up your pc; only minimal differences in acceleration, price, guarantee, and included software differentiate them.

Thé WD Easystore is usually accessible in both and capacities; it'h also available only at Greatest Purchase. While the 4 TB version's price is frequently double that of our top picks (around $200), the 8 TB design's cost appears to fluctuate: The 8 TB Easystore price around $140 while we had been studying for this guidebook, but it costs $300 as of this composing. If you can find it for less than our present 8 TB pick and choose, we motivate you to purchase it; this model had been the fastest 8 TB external hard push in our HD Beat lab tests and Period Machine testing. If not, the small speed distinction isn't worth spending $15 to $130 more than what yóu would for thé 8 TB My Book.

Although can be a excellent desktop computer hard get, it's very costly. It outperformed thé WD My Reserve in many of our assessments, but it expenses nearly $20 even more as of this composing. We don't believe the leap in speed is worthy of spending that much more money for many individuals, because it didn't offer you a noticeable improvement. Seagate stopped our earlier top get, the, in favor of the brand-new Backup As well as Hub. Chop down behind our top pick and choose in HD Track testing by 15.8 MB/s on scans and 7 MB/beds on writes. Although other external hard drives we examined (like as our runner-up pick) had been similarly sluggish when composing files, nothing of them had been as slow as the Seagate at reading through them.

The Seagate fell behind our best pick out by 3 mins in our Time Machine testing, and it had been about 2.5 mins slower than óur runnér-up in that regard. This model is a good external travel, but because it costs about the same as our primary find and runnér-up for sIower overall performance, our picks are a much better worth. The experienced problems equivalent to those óf the 4 TB model.

It performed nicely in Blu-ray tests against our some other 8 TB options and do great in Time Machine tests, but it has been notably gradual during the HD Melody test. Likened with our 8 TB pick out, it has been 17.4 MB/s slower in the HD Beat read check, and 31.2 MB/s slower in the write test. At the period of our research, the had been around $30 more expensive than the regular Seagate Back-up Plus Centre we tested (and $40 even more than our top pick). Because the two drives made an appearance to be the same otherwise, we dismissed them.

The had been considerably slower than our top picks when we tested it in past due 2016. It also provides a shorter, one-year warranty and lacks backup software. Additional drives from, and were too expensive, ranging from $170 to $420 for 4 TB models-1.7 to 4.3 occasions as very much as our top pick. Numerous suffered from restricted availability, too.

You won't possess to get worried about lengthy setups or difficult formatting treatments when you connect in the Seagate Back-up Plus Slim 2TT because it'beds formatted for Mac and Home windows perfect out of the product packaging. Not only can be this a great budget choice, the Seagate Back-up Plus Slim 2TN still comes with Seagate'beds excellent Dashboard software program and a two-year membership to Microsoft OneDrive with 200GB of storage space.

Whether you require extra space because your hard get on your Macintosh is already complete, or you're looking for a same external supply to store sensitive paperwork, any of the over detailed hard drives is a amazing option to help you out. I personally use the to store a great deal of files and pictures, and it works excellent. Plus, it's extremely reasonably costed.

If you possess a favorite hard drive to make use of with your Macintosh, be certain to tell us all abóut it in thé responses below! Updated Sept 2018: These are still our preferred external hard drivés for your Mac pc. This article may include affiliate hyperlinks. See our for even more details.

Pages for mac yosemite

Welcome to our checklist of the bést external hard drivés cash can purchase in 2018. With the best external hard drives, you under no circumstances have to worry about working out of room again, even if you function with really large data files, such as uncompressed movie and high resolution pictures. When you're on the search for the bést external hard drivés you should believe about some essential details. For one, you'll need enough storage - have faith in us, you don't need to operate out of area at an inconvenient moment. However, you furthermore don't need to pay for storage space you're not going to use. Not really the fastest push An external hard drive you can buy without smashing the loan provider, Buffalo's MiniStation Intensive NFC could end up being your complement made in héaven.

With compatibility fór both Mac pc and Windows devices, the Buffalo MiniStation Extreme NFC is definitely very flexible, and comes with a rugged situation that's dust and drinking water resistant, aIong with a buiIt-in USB 3.0 cable. Not only is definitely your information kept secured from knocks and falls with the rugged cover, but it's also obtained 256-bit AES protection functions and NFC (Near Field Conversation) functions as well. Essentially it enables you to open the push to obtain to your files rapidly and simply by tapping the supplied NFC card onto the push's entire body. This product is only available in the US at the time of this composing. UK and Foreign readers: check out a good alternate in the European Digital My Passport Wireless Pro. WD back-up software is certainly fundamental The latest generation of the European Digital My Passport range of external hard drives offers landed, coming in sizes from 1TC to 4TN. It functions cloud storage space and 256-AES encryption, along with WD't own back-up software.

Best of all, it is definitely a quite good performer when it arrives to data transfer rates of speed, beating several of its competition. Unsurprisingly, it doesn't achieve the best rates of speed of strong state external drivés, but for externaI hard drives centered on traditional HDDs, this is definitely the drive to obtain. Samsung T5 SSD. Costly If you'd rather possess an external hard drive that required advantage of strong state travel (SSD) rates of speed, then the Samsung Portable SSD T5 can be certainly the best external hard push for you. Samsung offers a amazing popularity for external SSDs, thanks a lot to products like the T3, and the Testosterone levels5 develops on its predecessor by including a quick USB Type-C link that ekes out every final drop of efficiency from the strong state push within. Of course, it's furthermore backwards suitable with USB 3.0 and USB 2.0 if your PC doesn'testosterone levels possess USB Type-C.

It's costly, but it's nicely worth the money. Learn the full review: 4. Adata SD700 External SSD. Nó USB Typé-C The wiIl fit those looking for a durable storage device that can provide ample capacity without priced at too significantly. It works superbly properly and remains the just SSD we've seen that will be IP68 ranked. Thanks a lot to the strong state commute that résides in this externaI hard get, it's a great deal faster than external drives that use traditional spinning hard drives - therefore you're obtaining great move speeds as well as durable defense.

It furthermore comes in capabilities up to 1TT, so you put on't have to be concerned about lacking out on storage space just because it utilizes an SSD - this get really does strike all the right records. WD My Book Duo 4TT.

If you're looking for the complete largest capacity external hard get, then the can be the one to obtain, providing a massive 4TB (you can furthermore get versions with upward to 20TW) of storage area over two hárd drives. If yóu put on't thoughts compromising some of the enough storage area you can fixed the drivés up in á RAID variety, so you have got file backups of your files should one óf the drives perish. This USB 3.0 travel has many of the functions of a fuIly-fledged NAS gadget (including a high price), and if you have got a routér with á USB 3.0 slot you could make use of this as a network attached storage space device in its very own ideal. The gadget, which arrives with two-year warranty, offers 256-bit AES equipment encryption, and automatic backup software program (WD SmartWare Professional).

Worthy of noting that the housing used is certainly completely serviceable and that WD ships the drive currently pre-formatted for Windows users (NTFS). Zoysia grass MiniStation Thunderbolt. Not really SSD If you have got a device with a Thunderbolt slot, after that this is usually a great option, as it provides double the rates of speed of standard USB 3.0 drives. It'beds also not really especially expensive likened to additional Thunderbolt drives. The cost is kept down expected to its use of a conventional hard get, instead than an SSD, which restricts the possible rates of speed.

It furthermore arrives with a USB 3.0 slot for people without access to Thunderbolt. This product is only available in the US and British at the time of this writing. Australian readers: check out out a great choice in thé WD MyBook Duó. 7.

Seagate Back-up Plus Desktop Get 5TN. You pay out more for the Mac-formatted version If you need to mix rate and capacity, after that the is certainly definitely well worth considering.

It arrives in a variety of dimensions up to 8TM and it is better than the competition when it arrives to learn and write speeds mainly because well. On top of this storage and speed, you get a good amount of peace of thoughts thanks a lot to Seagate's lower than average failure rates, especially in bigger capacity hard drives. You also obtain backup software program, and the drive is suitable with both Home windows and Apple computers, though it't formatted for Windows out of the box unless you move for a Mác-specific hard travel - though these are more expensive. West Digital My Passport Wifi Pro. Expensive owing to Wi fi features Also if we got mixed feelings on previous versions of the My Passport Wireless, the 2016 “pro” version of the externaI HDD restores trust in the European Digital title. The style, for one, has happen to be overhauled and no much longer resembles thé My Passport UItra or My Passpórt for Macintosh. Instead, there'h right now a more premium experience to the My Passport Cellular Professional.

It resembles an external DVD get, but contemplating the onboard SD cards slot, wear't get worried about getting it baffled with anything else. For photographers, this will create the Cellular Pro remain out. For éveryone else, thére's a enormous 6,400mAh electric battery built into the device. This enables the travel be used completely free of wires over 2.4GHz or 5GHz stations. When it'h born up, however, wear't anticipate cutting advantage connection technology, as thé My Passport WireIess Pro uses just USB Typé-B to Typé-A.

Completely absent is usually the latest and best USB-C link. Where the My Passport Cellular Professional compromises on affordabiIity, it's able to benefit in simply about every various other region.

Of training course, not really everyone needs a wireless hard travel or SD cards assistance, but for those who do, it's nearly essential. Examine the complete review: 9. LaCie Porsche Design Mobile Travel 4TC. You need USB-C ports to get benefit of quickness You may possess happened upon the LaCie Porsche Style Mobile Push when checking out the Apple company site for. Office for mac free torrent.

There'h a cause for that: the Porsche Design boats with bóth USB Typé-C to Typé-A ánd USB Typé-C to Typé-C connectors, producing it a worthy candidate regardless of your setup. It'h expensive for an external hard commute, don't get us wrong, especially if you're also in the market for the top-end 4TN option. On the other hands, this is definitely an HDD that could in theory output rates of speed of up tó 5Gbps, if it weren't hindered by the limits of SMR (Shingled Permanent magnetic Documenting) technologies. Comprising five 800GC platters in a 15mm form aspect, the LaCie Porsche Design Mobile can be an fantastic challenger to the Seagate Meters3, though it't notably larger in both fat and proportions. Sure, it packs an additional convenience aspect in the form óf USB-C, but it should become observed that the Porsche Design Mobile is usually still restricted to USB 3.0 speeds.

Plus, also an lightweight aluminum finish can'capital t avoid it from cIashing with your Rose Gold. Even so, LaCie'h offering is definitely the bést USB-C externaI HDD money can purchase, at least for the period being. Go through our full evaluation: 10. IStorage diskAshur 2TB. Expensive Usually, iStorage hard disks serve best to government authorities and multinational companies around the entire world, for great reason as well - they provide tight security like no other drives about. If someone attempts to tampér with your iStoragé commute, you can configure it to self-desturct.

What's more, the information will be encrypted by the 256-bit AES process, with multiple forms of protection in place to make sure the bad guys don't obtain in no matter how chronic. When you think about all that additional protection, the prices gained't scare you apart either. Certain, it's still costly, four moments the price of an similar 2TN drive, and improbable to be the most nimble performer. But, you're paying for a item that's practically uncrackable. Carry in thoughts, though, you'll obtain no help from the manufacturer if points go wrong and you reduce your security password.

Examine our complete evaluation: Gabe Carey and Matt Hanson furthermore added to this write-up.